Week 20/2023

“It’s the one with the fewest flaws,” said Indian director Satyajit Ray over his film Charulata. Based on a novella by Rabindranath Tagore, this delicate tale about a woman's forbidden desire for her husband's cousin opens with what is perhaps one of the most beautiful opening sequences in the history of cinema. Not only do the carefully orchestrated tracking shots and thought-out composition testify to Ray's cinematographic genius, but the scene also ingeniously acts as a microcosm of the film as a whole, foreshadowing aspects of its yet to unfold narrative though implicit hints and suggestions.

Forbidden desire is also at the heart of Valeska Grisebach's Sehnsucht, a slice of life portrait of a volunteer firefighter whose brief affair with a waitress leaves him conflicted. Like many of her colleagues from the 'new berlin school,' Grisebach's fiction films are greatly informed by her background in documentary filmmaking. By using documentary strategies, she shapes reality into fictions, or rather, uncovers the fictions woven into the fabric of reality. A key element in this interplay between artificiality and authenticity is the use of non-professional actors, whose real lives inevitably shine through in their acting, fusing their own story with that of their character.

One of the peculiarities of the history of Belgian cinema – if such a thing even exists – is that it began with a Frenchman. In 1909 Alfred Machin was sent to Belgium by the French production company Pathé to set up the first Belgian production studio, for which he directed several films himself. The selection of short films shown at DeCinema aptly illustrates Machin's position between tradition and modernity. Although the themes and plot are of the most traditional melodramatic kind, the cinematography and editing show his eagerness to explore the possibilities of the new medium.
 

Cārulatā
Charulata
Cārulatā , Satyajit Ray, 1964, 117’

Satyajit Ray’s exquisite story of a woman’s artistic and romantic yearning takes place in late nineteenth-century, pre-independence India, in the gracious home of a liberal-minded, workaholic newspaper editor and his lonely wife, Charulata. When her husband’s poet cousin comes to stay with them, Charulata finds herself both creatively inspired and dangerously drawn to him.

EN

“It’s the one with the fewest flaws.”

Satyajit Ray1

 

“In the opening segment of the film (roughly 7 and a half minutes), Ray takes full advantage of the cinematic apparatus at his disposal, in search of a ‘language entirely free from literary and theatrical influences’. Dialogue is almost done away with; sound cues and music are carefully selected and introduced with pin-point precision, and the action and camera movement are orchestrated to mediate between Charu’s reflective pauses and moments of acceleration. The end result is a wonderfully intricate, almost composed tableau that already discloses Ray’s thematic concerns as well as his formal approach.”

Neel Chaudhuri2

 

“There is a characteristic Ray scene – perhaps the characteristic Ray scene. A shadowed interior, shuttered against the sun; rooms rather large and cluttered, with the sounds of birds or animals just penetrating the walls; two people, arriving at some moment of discovery about themselves, caught in an instant of absorbed silence. Nothing is going to be said, because emotionally we are still in a climate of Victorian reticence. Writers as far apart as Henry James and Chekhov have known the power of such moments, when the tension (not necessarily sexual tension; it can take other forms) builds up against the safety-valve of social convention, and the suspense is in the unbreakable silence.”

Penelope Houston3

  • 1John Wakeman, World of Film Directors: 1890-1945 (California: H.W. Wilson, 1988), 845.
  • 2Neel Chaudhuri, “Charulata: The Intimacies of a Broken Nest,” Senses of Cinema, April 2004.
  • 3Penelope Houston, Sight & Sound, Winter 1965/66.
screening
Cinema RITCS, Brussels
Sehnsucht
Sehnsucht , Valeska Grisebach, 2006, 88’

“Even during shooting, it’s important to me to keep my eyes open for that which enters from outside: to seek out coincidence and to confront the story with it. Shooting is the moment in which to experience, to find out what is possible at this moment, in this place, with these people, with this story; for bringing together all the ingredients. Sometimes it’s a matter of intentionally subjecting oneself to a situation that is as real as possible or even one that is unplanned, uncertain – like a sparring partner of one’s imagination. An encounter with the story and everyone involved. And then you’ve got to catch the ball. The moment generates an inspiration. Realism separates itself from the melodramatic or fairy-talelike, resisting them with an unwieldy rawness. Roughness and laconism. In this context, even the physicality of actors and places plays a role: Their ‘being’, things one can’t invent, as reminders of reality – that which isn’t ‘by design’. Atmosphere – another resistance to the melodramatic – in a good sense banalizes the melodramatic.”

Valeska Grisebach1

 

“Neben dem konkreten, sichtbaren Leben, das man führt, haben mich immer die vielen anderen berührt, die nur in der Phantasie vorkommen: Wenn man an einem anderen Ort wäre, einen anderen Menschen getroffen, sich anders entschieden hätte, sich trauen würde etc. ... ‘Sehnsucht’ empfinde ich als etwas sehr Persönliches. Als wilde Kraft, die viel über einen Menschen erzählen und gleichzeitig auch eine bittersüße Prise Abschied, Verzicht in sich tragen kann. Manchmal ist das eine Leben zu klein. In den Interviews während der Recherche zum Film, hatte ich den Eindruck, dass Liebesgeschichten oft die Bühne für Sehnsüchte werden. Hier sollen Wünsche in Erfüllung gehen, das Aufregende passieren, das einen lebendig macht. Hier wird man zur dramatischen Figur, zeigt sein Gesicht. ... Der Mann in dieser Geschichte ist eine überhöhte, romantische Figur, im altmodischen Sinne fast ein Ehrenmann. Einer, der versucht alles richtig zu machen, Verantwortung zu übernehmen und darin scheitert. Es gibt keinen Schutz.”

Valeska Grisebach2

screening
CINEMATEK, Brussels
This Week
-

index